Wednesday, 25 January 2017

The Incoherence of William Lane Craig


Introduction

William Lane Craig is without a doubt one of the top representatives for Christianity alive today. With countless debates against renowned opponents, he does a very good job thrashing the atheists who debate him. Dr.Craig’s primary argument against atheists for the existence of God is what he calls the “Kalam Cosmological Argument” (KCA for short from now onwards).

The KCA in Dr.Craig's words:
P1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause of its beginning.
P2. The universe began to exist.
C1. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its beginning.

In this topic I will attempt to show why the KCA is incompatible with the Christian conception of God. This is because the KCA reaches conclusions that fundamentally contradict the Christian faith. Most significantly the conclusion that God is changeless.

The KCA and the Changelessness of God

One of the conclusions that follows from the KCA is that God is changeless. This is mainly because the KCA depends on the fact that the world changes in order to prove that the world began to exist (which is the second premise of the argument). Three reasons for the emergence of all changes will be briefly listed below:

-1- “Change” necessitates a new beginning. For a being that exists, "change" means a transition from one state (state-1) to another (state-2). When state-1 terminates, state-2 emerges. According to the first premise of the KCA, everything that emerges into existence is created. And since state-2 began to exist, state-2 is created. Thus to claim that God changes, is to claim that God is attributed with states that come and go. Those emerging states would be (according to the KCA) created. For the claimant, this means that God is at least in part created.

-2- It’s impossible for an infinity to come to an end, and the past ends with the present moment. From this we can know that the number of events (or changes) in the past is finite. As such there was a “first event” that emerged into existence. According to the first premise of the KCA, this first event would be in need of a Creator since it began to exist. If this creator was another event then it would not solve the problems of contingency, but would only push the goalposts back a step and extend the problem (this creator-event would itself be contingent upon a prior creator since it began to exist). Therefore the true Creator cannot be an event.

-3- Because a changing being accepts a multiplicity of states (either state-1 or state-2… etc.) then those states do not exist necessarily in of themselves. The first state terminated (it is succeeded by its non-existence) and the second began to exist (it is preceded by its non-existence). Therefore to claim that God changes, is to claim that He is attributed with states that do not exist necessarily. This by extension means God Himself does not exist necessarily. What follows from such a claim is that God is created.

In short, it would be hypocritical to claim that the world is emergent because it changes, but to then turn around and maintain that God is both eternal and changing. For this reason, one of the most fundamental conclusions of the KCA is that God is changeless.

The Incompatibility of Christianity

Dr.Craig understands that the KCA necessitates a changeless Creator, so the above is not the point of contention.

We find Dr.Craig writing in his article on the KCA: “Now the cause of the universe is permanently there, since it is timeless”

And in the same article he writes: "But one way to think about it is to envision God existing alone without the universe as changeless and timeless"

concluding his article with: “Ghazali’s cosmological argument thus gives us powerful grounds for believing in the existence of a beginningless, uncaused, timeless, spaceless, changeless, immaterial, enormously powerful, Personal Creator of the universe.”

However, the changelessness of God is very problematic for Christianity since Christians believe in an incarnation. So despite Dr.Craig’s admission that God is changeless, we find him preaching that the changeless Creator changed into a man, who walked and talked with the humans on earth, ate, slept, died and was resurrected.

How does Dr.Craig resolve this obvious contradiction between the KCA and Christianity? He does this by proposing that the changeless Creator entered time after creating time, and could since then change. Dr.Craig says in 1:07 of this video: “God is timeless without creation, and He is temporal since the moment of creation. So the decision to create on God’s part, is a decision to enter into time…”

And in the article he claims: “His free act of creation is a temporal event simultaneous with the universe’s coming into being. Therefore, God enters into time when He creates the universe. God is thus timeless without the universe and in time with the universe.”

Unfortunately Dr.Craig’s response does not solve anything. Dr.Craig argues that God must enter into time for God to change. However, this “entry into time” (which is supposedly the prerequisite to change) is itself an emergent temporal event. After all, a transition from timelessness to temporality is a change. So you’re still left with the exact same problem; the changing changeless Creator. In other words, since “entry to time” is a change, what Dr.Craig’s response boils down to is that “the changeless God must change before He can change” and that’s begging the question if anything at all.

Conclusion

The only way to maintain the KCA, is to believe that God is absolutely changeless. This is impossible on the Christian worldview, since Christians believe in the incarnation. So if Dr. William Lane Craig is consistent, he would either abandon the KCA or abandon his Christianity.

Wednesday, 11 January 2017

New Atheism Destroyed !

New Atheism Destroyed

A new illogical trend has emerged from the many illogical man-made religions that are out there. Intelligent thinking people have been turned off by the many Man-Made religions in the world, while at the same time they have done something even more illogical which is to deny the Creator who created them and this entire universe.
In this exciting Episode our guest is logically destroying the New Atheism. Thanks for tuning in! Enjoy !

Why I Left Atheism

Story of a young English man from Britain. Raised in a non-religious secular family, Believing science had all the answers and unhappy with the society around him. Having a Muslim friend who used to tell him about God and Islam he decided that it will not harm him and he had nothing to lose to find out for himself by looking into religion, and so his spiritual journey began.

Qadianism (Ahmadiyya): ALL MUSLIMS ARE INFIDELS (KAFIRS)

Ahmadiyya: ALL MUSLIMS ARE INFIDELS (KAFIRS)

Ahmadiyya Jamaat and their followers today pretend to be the champions of Islam, claiming to have exemplary character. They go to extra length to advertise that Muslims have labelled them Kaafir whereas they are very peace-loving sect of Islam, who has never labelled anyone KAAFIR. They raise the slogan: LOVE FOR ALL, HATRED FOR NONE. However in real life all these claims fly in the face. The founder of Ahmadiyya Movement, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani, has this to say about the Muslims (non-Ahmadi Muslims)

Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "Except for the CHILDREN OF PROSTITUTE, whose hearts have been sealed by God, everyone else believes in me and has accepted me."  (Aina-e-Kamalat-e-Islam, Roohani Khazain vol.5 p.547)
 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "God has revealed to me that anyone to whom my message has reached and he has not accepted me , he is not a muslim." (Letter of Mirza to Dr. Abdul Hakeem Khan Patialvi)
 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "I have God's inspiration that he who does not follow you and will not enter your Ba'ith and remain your opponent, he is disobedient of God and His Prophet, Hellish." (Advertisement in M'ayaar-ul-Akhyar by Mirza Ghulam p.8)
 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "Thus remember as God has informed me, it is forbidden and absolutely forbidden to pray behind any disbeliever and hesitant; but is should be that your imam should be one of you." (Arbaeen No 3, Roohani Khazain vol.17 p.417 footnote)
 

Some one asked a question and Mirza has replied to it. Both are mentioned in his book, Haqeeqat-ul-Wahi. I quote:

Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "Question: Huzoor-e-aali has mentioned in thousands of places that it is not at all right to call KAFIR a Kalima-go (one who recites a Kalima) and an Ahle-Qibla. It is quite obvious that except those Momineen who become Kafir by rejecting you, just by not accepting you no one becomes a Kafir. But you write to Abdul Hakeem Khan that anyone who has received my message and he has not accepted me, he is not Muslim. There is contradiction between this statement and the statements in previous books. Earlier in Tiryaq-ul-Quloob etc you had mentioned that no one becomes Kafir by not accepting you and now you are writing that by rejecting me he becomes a Kafir.
Answer: This is strange that you consider the person who rejects me and the person who calls me Kafir as two different persons, whereas in the eyes of God he is the same type; because he who does not accept me is because he considers me a fabricator.... apart from this, he who does not accept me, he does not believe in God and His Prophet as well, because there is God's and his Prophet's prophecy regarding me"  (Haqeeqat-ul-Wahi, Roohani Khazain vol.22 p.167)


Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "It is our obligation that we do not consider non-ahmadis as muslims and do not pray behind them, because for us they have rejected one prophet (Mirza Ghulam) of God. This is a religious matter and no one has any right to do anything in it."  (Anwar-e-Khilafat, by Mirza Mahmood, Khalifa 2, p.90)
 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "All muslims who are not included in the initiation of Maseeh Mowood, even if they have not heard the name of Maseeh Mowood, they are Kafir and out of the fold of Islam. I admit that these are my beliefs." (Aina-e-Sadaqat, by Mirza Mahmood, 2nd Khalifa, p.35) 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "Every one who accepts Moses but not Eesa or accepts Eesa but not Mohammad or accepts Mohammad but not Maseeh Mowood, he is not only Kafir but a hardened Kafir and is out of the fold of Islam. (Kalimat-alFasl by Mirza Basheer Ahmad s/o Mirza Ghulam p.110)
 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net Question: "Is it permitted to say May God Bless the departed soul, forgive him and send him to Paradise for a person who was not included in Ahmadiyyat?"
Answer: "The KUFR of non-Ahmadis is proven by evident signs and it is not permitted to ask for forgiveness for non-believers (KUFFAR)."  (Al-Fazl Qadian vol.8, No. 59, 7th Feb 1921)
 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "Non-Ahmadis are the disbelievers therefore their funeral prayers should not be offered, but if an infant of non-ahmadi dies, why should we not pray his funaral prayer, he is not a disbeliever of Maseeh Mowood? I ask the inquirer, that if this is true than why don't we offer funeral prayer of a Hindu or a Christian child? How many people offer their funeral prayer?" (Anwar-e-Khilafat, Mirza Mahmood, 2nd Khalifa, p.93)
 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "It is the order of Hazrat Maseeh Mowood and firm order that no ahmadi should give his daughter to non-ahmadi. It is obligatory on every ahmadi to carry it out..... there is great loss in it, besides this marriage is not permitted." (Barakat-e-Khilafat by Mirza Mehmood p.73)
 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "Our prayers are separate from Non-ahmadis, it is forbidden to give our girls to them, we are stopped to offer their funeral prayers. Now what is left that we can participate with them? There are only two kinds of relations - religious and worldly. For religious relations, it is the gathering for prayers and for worldly relations, it is the marriage and both are forbidden for us." (Mirza Basheer Ahmad s/o Mirza Ghulam, Kalimat alFasl p.169)
 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "The point is now quite clear. If it is 'Kufr' (infidelity) to deny the Gracious Prophet (Muhammad pbuh), it must also be 'Kufr' to deny the Promised Messiah, because the Promised Messiah is in no way a separate being from the Gracious Prophet; rather he is the same (Muhammad incarnate). If anyone is not deemed a Kafir for denying the Promised Messiah, then anyone else who denies the Gracious Prophet also cannot be considered a Kafir. How is it possible that denying him in his first birth as Prophet should be regarded as Kufr, but denying him in his (reincarnated) second birth as prophet should not be regarded as Kufr, when, as claimed by the Promised Messiah, his (Mirza's birth as Muhammad incarnate) spiritual attainment is stronger, complete and severe." (Kalimatul Fasl, pages 146-147, as cited in the Review of Religions, dated March-April 1915)
 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "Any person who believes in Moses but does not believe in Christ, or believes in Christ but does not believe in Muhammad, or believes in Muhammad but does not believe in the Promised Messiah, is not only a Kafir, but a 'pakka' (confirmed) Kafir, and (he is) out of the fold of Islam." (Kalimatul Fasl, page 110, by Mirza Bashir Ahmad, M.A.)
 
Islam - Discover the True Religion Islam, About Islam, Muslim, Quran, Religion, Allah, Muhammad, Islamic, God, muslims, moslem, koran, Hadith, Jesus, Prophet, Muhammed, muslim women, Sunnah, Salvation, Bible,Jesus, Mary, Sects,  Salafi, Allaahuakbar.net "All such Muslims who did not swear allegiance to the promised Masih (Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian), even though they did not hear the name of the Promised Masih, are Kafir and debarred from the fold of Islam." (Aiena-e-Sadaqat, page 35, by Mirza Mahmud Ahmad Qadiani).
source 

Golden ratio & atheism !


Mutations is not a proof for Darwinian evolution thery


Atheism and Hawkins refuted !